Unit 11 — Debate and Discussion

Template: Activate → Input → Practise → Produce → Reflect.
Niveau: G/M parallel. class test (“Klassenarbeit”) at Niveau M (45 BE).

Learning objectives#

  • I can present a 90-second argument for or against a motion.
  • I can use 6 debate signposts (I’d like to argue, my opponent claims, however, in response, finally, to summarise).
  • I can listen and respond to one specific point in a peer’s argument.

Bildungsplan alignment#

  • 3.2.1 Soziokulturelles Orientierungswissen / Themen
  • 3.2.3.1 Hör-/Hörsehverstehen
  • 3.2.3.3 Sprechen – an Gesprächen teilnehmen
  • 3.2.3.4 Sprechen – zusammenhängendes monologisches Sprechen

(Source: https://www.bildungsplaene-bw.de/,Lde/LS/BP2016BW/ALLG/SEK1/E1 )

Lead-in story#

Mr. Yilmaz proposed a class debate. The motion: This class would replace one written test per term with a project-based assessment. Naima leads the for. Eli leads the against. Mr. Yilmaz, who secretly favours both options, is moderator.

1. Activate#

Two-minute brainstorm. With your partner, list 3 arguments for and 3 against the motion.

2. Input#

Debate vocabulary#

motion, proposition, opposition, moderator, point of order, rebut, concede, argument, evidence, anecdote, summary.

Debate signposts#

Opening: I’d like to argue / I would like to speak in favour / against … Listing: Firstly … Secondly … Lastly … Counter: My opponent claims … / However, … / In response, … Concession: I accept that … but … Closing: Finally / To summarise / In short, I would urge you to support / oppose this motion.

3. Practise#

Niveau G#

  1. Choose: opening / counter / closing: “I’d like to argue …” → ___ ; “My opponent claims …” → ___ ; “To summarise …” → ___ .
  2. Match: rebut → counter; concede → accept partly. (T / F)

Niveau M#

  1. Build a 4-sentence opening for or against the motion using 3 signposts.
Answer key

G. 1. opening / counter / closing. 2. all true.

M. 3. Open.

4. Produce#

Class debate. Two teams of 4 + 1 moderator. Each speaker delivers a 90-second argument with 4 signposts. Listening team prepares one specific rebuttal per speaker. The moderator times strictly.

Sample#

I’d like to speak in favour of the motion. Firstly, project-based assessment captures skills that a written test cannot — research, design, presentation. Secondly, project-based work tends to involve real audiences, which makes the writing better. My opponent will claim that projects can be unfair across groups. I accept that, but it can be controlled with clear rubrics. Finally, replacing one test per term is moderate. To summarise: a small change, a real benefit. I urge you to support the motion.

5. Reflect#

One thing in your notebook: Write one sentence using something you learned in this Unit.

Exam example#

Open the separate assessment .

Teacher notes#

**Slide deck timing.** 45 minutes total. Lead-in 4 min · Activate 5 min · Input 14 min · Practise 8 min · Produce 11 min · Reflect 3 min.

Differentiation. Niveau G: scaffold card with the key structure. Above Niveau M: extension prompt linking to Klasse 10.

Common pitfalls#

  • Reading from a script flatly.
  • Generic rebuttals (you’re wrong) — be specific.
  • Concession without genuine engagement.

Further reading / listening#

  • ESU (English-Speaking Union) — student debate clips.
  • BBC Sounds — Question Time extracts.

Downloads

Listen

Audio and transcripts for this unit.

Text 1
Show text
Mr. Yilmaz proposed a class debate. The motion: This class would replace one written test per term with a project-based assessment. Naima leads the for. Eli leads the against. Mr. Yilmaz, who secretly favours both options, is moderator.
Vocabulary 1
Show text
motion · proposition · opposition · moderator · point of order · rebut · concede · argument · evidence · anecdote · summary