Unit 2 — Political Discourse, Advanced
Learning objectives#
- I can read / listen to longer political discourse and identify rhetorical structure, register-shifts, and dog-whistle vocabulary.
- I can use advanced rhetorical-analysis vocabulary (dog whistle, framing battle, scripted spontaneity, agenda-control, loaded antithesis).
- I can write a 450-word rhetorical-analysis essay sustaining argument.
curriculum framework (“Bildungsplan”) alignment#
- 3.4.1 / 3.5.1 Soziokulturelles Orientierungswissen / Themen
- 3.4.3.1 / 3.5.3.1 Hör-/Hörsehverstehen
- 3.4.3.2 / 3.5.3.2 Leseverstehen
- 3.4.4 / 3.5.4 Text- und Medienkompetenz
(Sources: https://www.bildungsplaene-bw.de/,Lde/LS/BP2016BW/ALLG/GYM/E1/IK/11-12-LF / https://www.bildungsplaene-bw.de/,Lde/LS/BP2016BW/ALLG/GYM/E1/IK/11-12-BF )
Lead-in story#
The class read the full text of three Westminster Prime Minister’s Questions (PMQs) sessions from different administrations. The shared question: how does each speaker control the agenda of the exchange when given six minutes? The class noticed that agenda-control is rarely about the topic; it is about which question gets answered with which answer.
1. Activate#
Agenda-control scan. With your partner, list 3 tactics a politician uses to redirect a question without obviously refusing to answer.
2. Input#
Reading — three PMQs paraphrased#
Speaker A answers a question on housing by shifting to the broader cost-of-living frame. Speaker B answers a question on immigration by deploying a loaded antithesis (not whether but how). Speaker C answers a question on climate policy by attacking the questioner’s constituency record. All three speakers are, technically, answering. None is doing what the question asked.
Vocabulary — advanced rhetorical analysis#
dog whistle, framing battle, scripted spontaneity, agenda-control, loaded antithesis, ad hominem, whataboutism, ideological scaffolding, prebuttal, talking-point discipline, register-shifting.
3. Practise#
Niveau E — controlled#
- Match: dog whistle → coded signal to a base; whataboutism → deflect via counter-accusation; scripted spontaneity → rehearsed casualness.
- T or F: agenda-control means refusing to answer; register-shifting means changing accent; loaded antithesis hides agreement inside contrast.
Niveau E — productive#
- Identify in each PMQs paraphrase: agenda-control tactic + register-shift + one rhetorical move.
4. Produce#
Rhetorical-analysis essay, 450 words. Pick one of the three PMQs. Identify rhetorical structure, register-shifts, and any dog-whistle vocabulary. Use 6 advanced rhetorical terms + 4 integrated quotes + 7 academic discourse markers + 2 cleft structures.
Sample#
Speaker B’s answer to the housing question is, technically, an answer; politically, it is a framing battle conducted at speed. The questioner asked: what will the government do about the 47,000 social-housing waiting list in this constituency? The Speaker’s response opens with a loaded antithesis — the question is not whether but how — that refuses the binary the questioner implicitly offered. Accordingly, by the third sentence the topic has migrated from social housing to the broader cost-of-living frame, where the Speaker has prepared talking-point discipline. The agenda-control move is recognisable but not, in this case, dishonest; it is, more specifically, a register-shift from constituency-particular to national-general, and the data the Speaker cites is real. By contrast, the dog-whistle vocabulary is where the analyst has to be most careful. The phrase those who play the system sits inside what looks like a neutral defence of housing allocation rules; the phrase, however, has a documented coded history in this party’s communications since 2018. It is precisely the phrase, more than any single argument, that signals to the activist base. More specifically, the scripted-spontaneity at the close — a self-correction that lets the Speaker repeat the dog-whistle phrase while appearing to reject it — is the most structurally manipulative move in the answer. In this regard, what looks like agenda-control is also a small, repeatable trick: include the loaded phrase, frame it inside a self-correction, and trust the activist base to hear the phrase, not the correction. It is precisely the layered structure that makes the answer rhetorically effective and analytically interesting. The questioner’s reply, in the next exchange, successfully forces the Speaker back to the 47,000 figure. The Speaker concedes the figure. The concession is, predictably, framed inside a second loaded antithesis — not whether the figure is real but what we are doing about it. The PMQs format rewards this kind of layered control. Caution is warranted; not every redirected answer is a dog whistle. Some are simply policy disagreement.
5. Reflect#
One thing in your notebook: Write one sentence using something you learned in this Unit.
Exam example#
Open the separate assessment .
Teacher notes#
Differentiation — support (below Niveau E).
Complete these frames to build one analytical paragraph about your chosen speaker (aim for three, then link them):
- The questioner asked about ___, but the speaker’s first move is ___, which shifts the exchange toward ___.
- This counts as agenda-control because ___, not because the speaker openly refuses to answer.
- One phrase worth examining is “___”; before calling it a dog whistle, I should ask whether ___.
- Useful linkers to join your points:
More specifically, …,By contrast, …,In this regard, …,Accordingly, ….
Extension (above Niveau E / Oberstufe).
Write a 500-word comparative analysis of two of the three speakers, arguing which one’s agenda-control is more rhetorically effective and which is more ethically defensible — and show why those two judgements do not have to align. Then add a short methodological coda (roughly 80 words) defending the evidential standard you applied before labelling any phrase a dog whistle, in the spirit of Lakoff’s framing analysis.
Common pitfalls#
- Don’t accuse without evidence — dog whistle claims need a documented coded history.
- Agenda-control is not synonymous with bad faith.
- Quote integration is part of the analysis, not a decoration.
Further reading / listening#
- Sam Leith, You Talkin’ to Me? (later chapters).
- George Lakoff, Don’t Think of an Elephant! (framing).
Downloads
Listen
Audio and transcripts for this unit.

