Unit 3 — Science and Ethics

Template: Activate → Input → Practise → Produce → Reflect.
Niveau: E. Klausur (assessment) at Niveau E (90 BE).
Course tagging: basic course (Basisfach, E-BF) and advanced course (Leistungsfach, E-LF).

Learning objectives#

  • I can read short ethics-of-science texts (CRISPR, large language models, climate intervention) and identify the consequentialist and deontological moves.
  • I can use vocabulary of science ethics (precautionary principle, dual use, informed consent, moratorium, governance).
  • I can write a 350-word science-ethics essay with a structured ethical argument.

curriculum framework (“Bildungsplan”) alignment#

  • 3.4.1 / 3.5.1 Soziokulturelles Orientierungswissen / Themen
  • 3.4.3.2 / 3.5.3.2 Leseverstehen
  • 3.4.3.5 / 3.5.3.5 Schreiben
  • 3.4.4 / 3.5.4 Text- und Medienkompetenz

(Sources: https://www.bildungsplaene-bw.de/,Lde/LS/BP2016BW/ALLG/GYM/E1/IK/11-12-LF / https://www.bildungsplaene-bw.de/,Lde/LS/BP2016BW/ALLG/GYM/E1/IK/11-12-BF )

Lead-in story#

Mr. Yilmaz set three short ethics-of-science texts: one on CRISPR germline editing, one on large language models and academic integrity, one on climate intervention research (stratospheric aerosol injection). The class noticed quickly that all three debates rotated around the same question — who decides what we are not allowed to find out?

1. Activate#

Ethics scan. With your partner, list 3 scientific research areas you think should be regulated more strictly. Mark each with the strongest argument for and against.

2. Input#

Reading — Three Ethics Frames (paraphrased)#

Consequentialism asks what produces the best outcomes? — including risks, who bears them, and across what time horizon. Deontology asks what are we required to do regardless of consequences? — informed consent, dignity, irreversible-harm thresholds. Virtue ethics asks what kind of researcher / institution do we want to be?. Real-world ethics-of-science debates almost always combine all three; pretending the debate is purely consequentialist is itself a philosophical position.*

Vocabulary — science ethics#

precautionary principle, dual-use research, informed consent, moratorium, governance, irreversibility, externality, stakeholder engagement, transparency, peer review, replication, bioethics committee, IRB.

3. Practise#

Niveau E — controlled#

  1. Match: precautionary principle → caution under uncertainty; dual use → research with both civilian and military potential; moratorium → temporary halt.
  2. T or F: consequentialism rules out informed consent; deontology rules out cost-benefit thinking.

Niveau E — productive#

  1. Build 4 sentences applying consequentialist + deontological + virtue-ethics moves to the CRISPR case.
Answer key

Controlled. 1. all true. 2. F (consequentialism includes consent under expected-value), F (deontology accepts cost-benefit as a secondary tool, not primary).

Productive. 3. Open.

4. Produce#

Science-ethics essay, 350 words. Pick one case (CRISPR / LLMs / climate intervention). Build a structured argument with one consequentialist move + one deontological move + one virtue-ethics move + one disagreement / acknowledgement. Use 4 academic discourse markers + 1 cleft.

Sample#

The CRISPR-Cas9 germline editing debate is instructive precisely because all three major ethics frames push in slightly different directions, and the resulting policy must be assembled from their overlap. The consequentialist case for some forms of germline editing is, on its own terms, strong: if a single safe intervention can prevent Huntington’s disease in a future child, the expected welfare gain is large and the risk profile, with current CRISPR-Cas9 v3 protocols, is modest. By contrast, the deontological objection is also strong: the future child cannot consent, and the principle of informed consent has, since the Belmont Report (1979), been a non-negotiable in human-subject research. Accordingly, the most useful frame here is the precautionary principle — not the strong version (any risk, no action) but the weak version (irreversible-harm thresholds plus stakeholder engagement). The virtue-ethics question — what kind of researcher community do we want? — tilts toward a moratorium-with-review, partly because the researcher community after the He Jiankui case (2018) has, on reflection, agreed that the breach of governance norms was itself the primary harm. It is precisely this institutional self-correction that makes the moratorium-with-review frame defensible. In this regard, the case is not for or against germline editing but for or against doing it inside a peer-reviewed, consent-respecting governance structure. The honest answer is conditional. Some applications, with strong governance, may be permissible; others, without it, are not. The frame is what travels.

5. Reflect#

One thing in your notebook: Write one sentence using something you learned in this Unit.

Exam example#

Open the separate assessment .

Teacher notes#

**Slide deck timing.** 90 minutes total (Doppelstunde). Lead-in 6 min · Activate 8 min · Input 25 min · Practise 15 min · Produce 30 min · Reflect 6 min.

Differentiation — support (below Niveau E).

Complete these starters to build your essay’s three moves on one case (CRISPR / LLMs / climate intervention):

  • Consequentialist move: If we allow ___ , the likely outcome is ___ , and the people who carry the risk are ___ .
  • Deontological move: Regardless of the benefits, we are still required to ___ , because ___ .
  • Virtue-ethics move: A responsible research community would ___ , since the kind of scientists we want to be ___ .
  • Acknowledgement: Some would object that ___ ; however, ___ .

Useful discourse markers: by contrast, accordingly, in this regard, on balance.

Extension (above Niveau E / Oberstufe).

Instead of arguing one case, write a 400-word comparative analysis of two cases (for example CRISPR germline editing versus stratospheric aerosol injection) and argue which of the three ethics frames does the most decisive work in each — and why a frame that settles one debate fails to settle the other. Then defend a single procedural principle capable of governing both, anticipating and dismantling the strongest objection to it.

Common pitfalls#

  • Don’t reduce ethics-of-science to yes / no.
  • Precautionary principle has a strong and a weak version — flag which.
  • Don’t quote ethics jargon; integrate it.

Further reading / listening#

  • Henry T. Greely, CRISPR People (accessible chapters).
  • The Atlantic — Tech Ethics essays.

Downloads

Listen

Audio and transcripts for this unit.

Text 1
Show text
Mr. Yilmaz set three short ethics-of-science texts: one on CRISPR germline editing, one on large language models and academic integrity, one on climate intervention research (stratospheric aerosol injection). The class noticed quickly that all three debates rotated around the same question — who decides what we are not allowed to find out?
Text 2
Show text
Consequentialism asks what produces the best outcomes? — including risks, who bears them, and across what time horizon. Deontology asks what are we required to do regardless of consequences? — informed consent, dignity, irreversible-harm thresholds. Virtue ethics asks what kind of researcher / institution do we want to be?. Real-world ethics-of-science debates almost always combine all three; pretending the debate is purely consequentialist is itself a philosophical position.*
Vocabulary 1
Show text
precautionary principle · dual-use research · informed consent · moratorium · governance · irreversibility · externality · stakeholder engagement · transparency · peer review · replication · bioethics committee · IRB