Unit 6 — Media Literacy, Advanced

Template: Activate → Input → Practise → Produce → Reflect.
Niveau: E. Klausur (assessment) at Niveau E (90 BE, Comprehension + Analysis + Composition + Mediation).
Course tagging: basic course (Basisfach, E-BF) and advanced course (Leistungsfach, E-LF) — Units in Klasse 11–13 carry both where applicable; some Units are tagged BF or LF specifically.

Learning objectives#

  • I can read a long-form journalistic piece and identify the writer’s framing, sourcing pattern, and one disclosed limitation.
  • I can use academic critique vocabulary (frame, framing effect, sourcing, attribution, anonymisation, conflict of interest).
  • I can write a 300-word media-criticism essay.

curriculum framework (“Bildungsplan”) alignment#

  • 3.4.1 / 3.5.1 Soziokulturelles Orientierungswissen / Themen
  • 3.4.3.2 / 3.5.3.2 Leseverstehen
  • 3.4.3.5 / 3.5.3.5 Schreiben
  • 3.4.4 / 3.5.4 Text- und Medienkompetenz

(Sources: https://www.bildungsplaene-bw.de/,Lde/LS/BP2016BW/ALLG/GYM/E1/IK/11-12-LF / https://www.bildungsplaene-bw.de/,Lde/LS/BP2016BW/ALLG/GYM/E1/IK/11-12-BF )

Lead-in story#

Maja read a 1,200-word piece by an English-language outlet on a contested local protest. She underlined the verbs of attribution. By the end she had counted: said 11 times, insisted 3, claimed 4, denied 1, added 2. She wrote in the margin: verbs of attribution are votes.

1. Activate#

Attribution scan. On the slide are three sentences with three different attribution verbs (said, claimed, insisted). With your partner, rank by neutrality.

2. Input#

Reading — Verbs of Attribution#

Long-form journalism is, mostly, a question of framing and verbs. The frame is what the article treats as the question; everything before the subhead is doing frame work. The verbs of attribution carry, accordingly, more weight than their dictionary definitions suggest. Said is neutral; claimed signals doubt; insisted signals stubbornness; added signals subordination. A reader who counts the verbs already knows half the writer’s argument before they reach the conclusion.

Vocabulary — media critique (advanced)#

frame, framing effect, agenda-setting, sourcing, anonymous source, on-the-record, off-the-record, attribution verb, lede, nut graf, disclosure, conflict of interest, false balance, both-sidesing, structural balance.

3. Practise#

Niveau E — controlled#

  1. Rank attribution verbs by neutrality (most neutral first): insisted, said, claimed, added, denied.
  2. Match: lede → article opening; nut graf → core-argument paragraph; both-sidesing → false balance.

Niveau E — productive#

  1. Build 4 sentences using 4 advanced media-critique terms about a long-form article.
Answer key

Controlled. 1. said > added > insisted > denied > claimed (rough ranking; added and denied depend on context). 2. all true.

Productive. 3. Open.

4. Produce#

Media-criticism essay, 300 words. Pick a long-form article. Identify framing, sourcing, attribution pattern, and one disclosed limitation. Use 5 advanced media-critique terms + 2 hedges.

Sample#

The article frames the protest as a question of public order versus expression. This is itself a framing choice; an alternative frame — housing-rights protest — would have produced a different piece. Accordingly, the lede privileges police concerns, and the nut graf does not appear until paragraph four. The sourcing pattern is asymmetric: the police source is on-the-record and named; the two protester sources are anonymous, citing fear of professional consequences. This asymmetry is disclosed in a half-sentence late in the piece, which is a transparent if minimal acknowledgement. The attribution verbs do, however, do most of the covert work. The police source says and adds; the anonymous protesters insist and claim. By the end of the article, the careful reader has been voted at — without a single fact having to bend. However, the piece is not, in my view, dishonest. It is conventionally framed in a way that a neighbouring outlet would frame differently. The more useful critique is structural: the routine choice of public order as the default frame is not decided by individual writers but by the desk above them. Caution is warranted; readers who count attribution verbs will, in this regard, get more out of long-form than readers who don’t. The framing habit, like the verbs, is teachable.

5. Reflect#

One thing in your notebook: Write one sentence using something you learned in this Unit.

Exam example#

Open the separate assessment .

Teacher notes#

**Slide deck timing.** 90 minutes total (Doppelstunde — typical in the Oberstufe). Lead-in 6 min · Activate 8 min · Input 25 min · Practise 15 min · Produce 30 min · Reflect 6 min.

Differentiation — support (below Niveau E).

Complete these frames about your chosen article to build the essay step by step:

  • The article frames the story as a question of _____ rather than _____.
  • The sourcing is uneven: the _____ source is named and on-the-record, while the _____ source stays anonymous because _____.
  • The attribution verbs do quiet work — the first source says, but the second source claims or insists.
  • The writer discloses one limitation only _____ (where in the piece), which is a small but honest admission.

Extension (above Niveau E / Oberstufe).

Take one event reported by two different English-language outlets and write a comparative critique: show how each publication’s default frame, sourcing hierarchy, and choice of attribution verbs steer the reader toward a different conclusion from the same facts. Then argue whether the divergence is best explained as individual editorial judgement or as structural desk-level habit, and close with a hedged verdict on which frame serves the reader better. Integrate at least seven advanced media-critique terms and sustain a single controlling thesis throughout.

Common pitfalls#

  • Don’t conflate biased and dishonest.
  • Anonymous sources can be legitimate — flag the reason given.
  • Attribution verbs are signals, not proofs.

Further reading / listening#

  • Reuters Institute Digital News Report.
  • Columbia Journalism Review — accessible essays.

Downloads

Listen

Audio and transcripts for this unit.

Text 1
Show text
Maja read a 1,200-word piece by an English-language outlet on a contested local protest. She underlined the verbs of attribution. By the end she had counted: said 11 times, insisted 3, claimed 4, denied 1, added 2. She wrote in the margin: verbs of attribution are votes.
Text 2
Show text
Long-form journalism is, mostly, a question of framing and verbs. The frame is what the article treats as the question; everything before the subhead is doing frame work. The verbs of attribution carry, accordingly, more weight than their dictionary definitions suggest. Said is neutral; claimed signals doubt; insisted signals stubbornness; added signals subordination. A reader who counts the verbs already knows half the writer's argument before they reach the conclusion.
Vocabulary 1
Show text
frame · framing effect · agenda-setting · sourcing · anonymous source · on-the-record · off-the-record · attribution verb · lede · nut graf · disclosure · conflict of interest · false balance · both-sidesing · structural balance