Unit 11 — Public Speaking and Debate
Learning objectives#
- I can deliver a 4-minute argued speech with three movements.
- I can rebut one specific point and concede one gracefully.
- I can listen to a peer’s speech and respond with one targeted argument.
curriculum framework (“Bildungsplan”) alignment#
- 3.3.1 Soziokulturelles Orientierungswissen / Themen
- 3.3.3.1 Hör-/Hörsehverstehen
- 3.3.3.3 Sprechen – an Gesprächen teilnehmen
- 3.3.3.4 Sprechen – zusammenhängendes monologisches Sprechen
(Source: https://www.bildungsplaene-bw.de/,Lde/LS/BP2016BW/ALLG/SEK1/E1 )
Lead-in story#
Maja’s class is rehearsing for the school debate society. The motion: This house would replace one written test per term with a project-based assessment. The team in favour was, predictably, the one with the project-people. The team against was, less predictably, also the one with one project-person — Mr. Yilmaz had drawn names from a hat.
1. Activate#
Argument scan. With your partner, list 3 best arguments for and 3 against the motion. Mark each as strong / mid / weak.
2. Input#
Speech — three movements (extended)#
- Frame (45 sec): the motion in your own words + why now.
- Argument (3 min): two points, each with one source / example, plus one anticipated counter and one specific rebuttal.
- Close (15 sec): one sentence + one ask.
Plus 30 sec buffer.
Debate signposts (extended)#
Opening: I’d like to argue / The motion before us … Listing: Firstly … Secondly … Lastly … Counter: My opponent will claim … / However, this misses … / In response, … Concession: I accept that … but … Closing: I urge you to support / oppose this motion.
3. Practise#
Niveau E — controlled#
- Match phrase to function: In response → counter; I accept that → concession; To summarise → closing.
- Build a 3-line opening for for the motion.
Niveau E — productive#
- Build a 4-minute argued speech outline (bullets) for or against the motion.
4. Produce#
Class debate (4 minutes per speaker). Two teams of 4. Each speaker delivers a 4-minute argued speech. Listening team prepares one specific rebuttal per speaker. Moderator times strictly.
Sample#
The motion before us is that this house would replace one written test per term with a project-based assessment. I’d like to argue in favour. Firstly, project-based assessment captures skills that a written test cannot — research, design, presentation, and the management of one’s own time. The available evidence — including a 2024 OECD review of 18 OECD countries — suggests modest improvements in transferable skill scores when project assessment is added to the mix. Secondly, project work tends to involve real audiences, which improves the writing. My opponent will claim, fairly, that fairness is harder to police across project formats. I accept that, but a clear marking rubric, agreed in advance, solves the lion’s share of that problem. To summarise: replacing one test per term is moderate; the gain is real; the fairness concern is manageable. I urge you to support the motion.
5. Reflect#
One thing in your notebook: Write one sentence using something you learned in this Unit.
Exam example#
Open the separate assessment .
Teacher notes#
Differentiation — support (below Niveau E).
Speak your speech with these starters — fill each blank and say the whole line aloud:
- Frame: The motion is that we should ___ . I speak in favour of / against it because ___ .
- First point: Firstly, ___ . One example of this is ___ .
- Counter + rebuttal: Some people will say ___ . I accept that, but ___ .
- Close: To sum up, ___ . I ask you to support / oppose the motion.
Extension (above Niveau E / Oberstufe).
Deliver your 4-minute speech, then write a 150-word “opponent’s brief”: build the single strongest case against your own position, name the one concession that most weakens your argument, and explain in one sentence why you still hold your stance. Draw on a technique from a named speaker or debating tradition (e.g. Cicero’s structure, or a Churchillian close) to sharpen your rebuttal, and be ready to defend the choice.
Common pitfalls#
- Reading flatly from a script.
- Generic rebuttal (you’re wrong) — name the specific claim you reject.
- Concession without engagement.
Further reading / listening#
- ESU (English-Speaking Union) — student debate footage.
- BBC Sounds — Question Time extracts.
Downloads
Listen
Audio and transcripts for this unit.

