Unit 11 — Debate and Discussion

Template: Activate → Input → Practise → Produce → Reflect.
Niveau: E. class test (“Klassenarbeit”) at Niveau E (45 BE).

Learning objectives#

  • I can present a 90-second argument for or against a motion.
  • I can use 6 debate signposts (I’d like to argue, my opponent claims, however, in response, finally, to summarise).
  • I can listen and respond to one specific point in a peer’s argument.

curriculum framework (“Bildungsplan”) alignment#

  • 3.2.1 Soziokulturelles Orientierungswissen / Themen
  • 3.2.3.1 Hör-/Hörsehverstehen
  • 3.2.3.3 Sprechen – an Gesprächen teilnehmen
  • 3.2.3.4 Sprechen – zusammenhängendes monologisches Sprechen

(Source: https://www.bildungsplaene-bw.de/,Lde/LS/BP2016BW/ALLG/SEK1/E1 )

Lead-in story#

Mr. Yilmaz proposed a class debate. The motion: This class would replace one written test per term with a project-based assessment. Naima leads the for. Eli leads the against. Mr. Yilmaz, who secretly favours both options, is moderator.

1. Activate#

Two-minute brainstorm. With your partner, list 3 arguments for and 3 against the motion.

2. Input#

Debate vocabulary#

motion, proposition, opposition, moderator, point of order, rebut, concede, argument, evidence, anecdote, summary.

Debate signposts#

Opening: I’d like to argue / I would like to speak in favour / against … Listing: Firstly … Secondly … Lastly … Counter: My opponent claims … / However, … / In response, … Concession: I accept that … but … Closing: Finally / To summarise / In short, I would urge you to support / oppose this motion.

3. Practise#

Niveau E — controlled#

  1. Choose: opening / counter / closing: “I’d like to argue …” → ___ ; “My opponent claims …” → ___ ; “To summarise …” → ___ .
  2. Match: rebut → counter; concede → accept partly. (T / F)

Niveau E — productive#

  1. Build a 4-sentence opening for or against the motion using 3 signposts.
Answer key

Controlled. 1. opening / counter / closing. 2. all true.

Productive. 3. Open.

4. Produce#

Class debate. Two teams of 4 + 1 moderator. Each speaker delivers a 90-second argument with 4 signposts. Listening team prepares one specific rebuttal per speaker. The moderator times strictly.

Sample#

I’d like to speak in favour of the motion. Firstly, project-based assessment captures skills that a written test cannot — research, design, presentation. Secondly, project-based work tends to involve real audiences, which makes the writing better. My opponent will claim that projects can be unfair across groups. I accept that, but it can be controlled with clear rubrics. Finally, replacing one test per term is moderate. To summarise: a small change, a real benefit. I urge you to support the motion.

5. Reflect#

One thing in your notebook: Write one sentence using something you learned in this Unit.

Exam example#

Open the separate assessment .

Teacher notes#

**Slide deck timing.** 45 minutes total. Lead-in 4 min · Activate 5 min · Input 14 min · Practise 8 min · Produce 11 min · Reflect 3 min.

Differentiation — support (below Niveau E).

Complete these frames to build a shorter 4-sentence speech on the motion:

  • I would like to speak (for / against) the motion, because ___.
  • Firstly, a project would let us ___, which a written test cannot.
  • My opponent might say ___, but I think ___.
  • To summarise, I urge you to (support / oppose) this motion.

Extension (above Niveau E / Oberstufe).

Take the role of moderator and, after both teams have spoken, deliver a 90-second impartial summary that fairly restates the strongest argument on each side, names the single point where the two teams genuinely disagree, and proposes one compromise motion that neither team has yet suggested. Then explain in two sentences why a debate rewards the speaker who anticipates objections rather than the one who simply repeats their own claims most loudly.

Common pitfalls#

  • Reading from a script flatly.
  • Generic rebuttals (you’re wrong) — be specific.
  • Concession without genuine engagement.

Further reading / listening#

  • ESU (English-Speaking Union) — student debate clips.
  • BBC Sounds — Question Time extracts.

Downloads

Listen

Audio and transcripts for this unit.

Text 1
Show text
Mr. Yilmaz proposed a class debate. The motion: This class would replace one written test per term with a project-based assessment. Naima leads the for. Eli leads the against. Mr. Yilmaz, who secretly favours both options, is moderator.
Vocabulary 1
Show text
motion · proposition · opposition · moderator · point of order · rebut · concede · argument · evidence · anecdote · summary