Unit 9 — School Rules and Rights

Template: Activate → Input → Practise → Produce → Reflect.
Niveau: E. class test (“Klassenarbeit”) at Niveau E.

Learning objectives#

  • I can read a short text about a school rule and explain who is affected and why the rule exists.
  • I can use modals of obligation (must, mustn’t, should, can) and passive present to write about rules.
  • I can write a 100-word opinion text on a school rule with one reason for, one reason against, and a conclusion.

Bildungsplan alignment#

  • 3.2.1 Themen — school life, rules, rights.
  • 3.2.2 Interkulturelle kommunikative Kompetenz — comparing school cultures.
  • 3.2.3.2 Leseverstehen — short opinion-shaped news text.
  • 3.2.3.5 Schreiben — short opinion text with conclusion.
  • 3.2.3.8 Grammatik — modals; present passive.
  • 3.2.4 Text- und Medienkompetenz — recognise position vs. evidence in a school-rules debate.

Lead-in story#

Ms. Reyes wrote the new school rules on the board: phones in boxes at the gate, no caps in lessons, no soft drinks in the classrooms. The class read the list. Aisha put up her hand. “Who made these rules?” Ms. Reyes said, “Adults.” Aisha said, “Adults who go to school here?” Ms. Reyes paused. “That’s a fair question. We should put it on the agenda.”

1. Activate#

Five-rule scan. On the slide there is a list of ten possible school rules. With your partner, choose five you think your school should have. For each one, write two words: who benefits and who is restricted.

This task makes the class notice that even fair rules cost someone something. Useful frame for the rest of the Unit.

2. Input#

Reading text — Phones in Pouches#

Ardenfield Comprehensive in Manchester has a “phones-in-pouches” rule. Every morning, students put their phones into a magnetic pouch and keep the pouch with them all day. The pouch can only be unlocked by a teacher or in the office. The headteacher, Mr Atta, says the rule has cut bullying messages and fights at break time. Some pupils complain it feels like a prison rule. Mr Atta replies: “We are open to a different rule. Bring me one that works.”

Language focus — modals of obligation/permission#

ModalMeaningExample
muststrong obligationStudents must put phones in the pouch.
mustn’tprohibitionYou mustn’t unlock the pouch yourself.
shouldrecommendationWe should review the rule.
shouldn’trecommendation againstWe shouldn’t ban phones without discussion.
canpermission/abilityTeachers can help if there’s an emergency.
can’tno permissionStudents can’t unlock the pouch.
have toexternal obligationWe have to wear the school uniform.

Mustn’t (prohibition) and don’t have to (no obligation) are not the same. You mustn’t park here — forbidden. You don’t have to park here — you can if you want, but you don’t need to.

Language focus — present passive#

We use the passive when the action matters more than who does it.

  • The pouches are sold at the office. (we don’t care who sells)
  • The rule is reviewed every term.
  • Pupils are asked to put phones in pouches.

Form: to be (in tense) + past participle.

3. Practise#

Niveau G — controlled#

A. Modal gap-fill.

  1. Students __________ (must / can) bring water bottles, but they __________ (mustn’t / can’t) bring soft drinks.
  2. We __________ (should / mustn’t) wear smart shoes for trips.
  3. Teachers __________ (can / mustn’t) ask pupils to leave class if needed.

B. Active → passive transformation.

  1. The teacher locks the pouch. → The pouch ___ .
  2. The school sells the pouches. → The pouches ___ .

Niveau M — productive#

C. Rule-writing. Turn each idea into one rule using a modal.

  1. (no caps in lessons) → ___
  2. (everyone respects break time) → ___
  3. (food only in the canteen) → ___

D. Passive in context. Rewrite using the passive.

  1. The headteacher reviews the rules every term. → ___ .
  2. The teachers approve all changes. → ___ .
Answer key

Niveau G

A. 1. can / mustn’t, 2. should, 3. can.
B. 4. The pouch is locked by the teacher. 5. The pouches are sold by the school.

Niveau M

  1. Sample: Pupils mustn’t wear caps in lessons.
  2. Sample: Everyone should respect break time.
  3. Sample: Food can only be eaten in the canteen.
  4. The rules are reviewed by the headteacher every term.
  5. All changes are approved by the teachers.

4. Produce#

Writing task — One Rule I Would Change. Write 100–120 words about one rule at your school you would keep and one you would change. For each, use a modal and one passive structure.

Sample student response (Niveau M, 116 words)#

One rule I would keep is the no-running rule in the corridors. The corridors are crowded between lessons, and someone could easily get hurt. Pupils must walk and step aside for younger students. One rule I would change is the cap rule. Caps are banned in lessons, but they don’t disturb anyone. I think pupils should be allowed to wear them in winter when the heating is off, although I would also accept a rule that says caps are only allowed if the windows are open. The point is that small rules are noticed every day. Big ones are easier to forget.

5. Reflect#

One sentence in your notebook: What is one rule I would propose if I had to write a new one?

Exam example#

Open the separate assessment .

Teacher notes#

**Slide deck timing.** 45 minutes total.
  • Title + Lead-in (4 min). Aisha’s Adults who go to school here? line. Useful for opening attention.
  • Activate (6 min). Five-rule scan in pairs.
  • Input (12 min). Read Phones in Pouches. Modal table on board. Mini-lesson on present passive with two examples.
  • Practise (10 min). Niveau split.
  • Produce (10 min). Silent writing.
  • Reflect (3 min).

Differentiation — support (below Niveau E).

Complete these sentence frames to build your text. Fill each gap with a rule and a reason:

  • One rule I would keep is ______, because ______.
  • Pupils must ______, and ______ is checked by the teacher.
  • One rule I would change is ______, because I think it ______.
  • Pupils should be allowed to ______, although ______.

Extension (above Niveau E / Oberstufe).

Instead of judging two rules, write a short “code of conduct” clause for one contested school rule (for example, phones or caps) that both a strict headteacher and a doubtful pupil could accept, then add a paragraph explaining exactly which conditions you built in to satisfy each side and why a compromise here is fairer than a simple ban. Argue in a formal register using modals of obligation, present passive, and at least one conditional (unless / provided that), and finish by comparing your clause with how the same issue might be handled at a school in another country.

Common pitfalls#

  • must not vs. don’t have to: prohibition vs. no obligation.
  • should + base verb (no to): We should review. — not We should to review.
  • Passive auxiliary mismatch: The rules is reviewed → ✗ / are reviewed → ✓.
  • Translating German Schulordnung with school order: use school rules or code of conduct.

Further reading / listening#

Downloads

Listen

Audio and transcripts for this unit.

Text 1
Show text
Ms. Reyes wrote the new school rules on the board: phones in boxes at the gate, no caps in lessons, no soft drinks in the classrooms. The class read the list. Aisha put up her hand. "Who made these rules?" Ms. Reyes said, "Adults." Aisha said, "Adults who go to school here?" Ms. Reyes paused. "That's a fair question. We should put it on the agenda."
Text 2
Show text
Ardenfield Comprehensive in Manchester has a "phones-in-pouches" rule. Every morning, students put their phones into a magnetic pouch and keep the pouch with them all day. The pouch can only be unlocked by a teacher or in the office. The headteacher, Mr Atta, says the rule has cut bullying messages and fights at break time. Some pupils complain it feels like a prison rule. Mr Atta replies: "We are open to a different rule. Bring me one that works."